Am I Adding Value as a Coach?

Nov 02, 2026

What if the pressure to prove our value as a coach is getting in the way of the space our client needs?

In this episode, we explore a question that comes up frequently in coaching supervision: “Am I adding value as a coach?” Whether we are beginning our coaching journey or have years of experience, that question can bring uncertainty, self-doubt and a strong desire to know we are doing meaningful work.

We begin by looking beneath the question itself. Are we wondering whether our client is making progress, whether we chose the right intervention, or whether we are good enough? Wanting to do our work well is natural. But when our attention shifts towards securing reassurance, we can lose connection with the person in front of us.

Together, we reflect on who gets to decide what valuable coaching looks like. As coaches, we might look for a breakthrough, a decision or a clear action. Our client might value something quieter: uninterrupted thinking time, the chance to say something aloud for the first time, or a question that leaves them seeing their situation differently. Coaching effectiveness is not always visible within the session.

One story brings this uncertainty into focus. Early in our coaching experience, a client finished an engagement describing the conversations as interesting but struggling to identify what they had gained. The experience left a sense of disappointment and questions about whether enough had been done. Around ten years later, that client made contact and described the coaching as the single biggest influence on a significant life change. The impact had developed beyond the time we shared.

We also explore why greater experience does not necessarily remove coaching self-doubt. Previous client transformations, recommendations and a growing toolkit can create pressure to deliver something equally significant every time. Non-directive coaching asks us to notice that pressure and remain responsive to the client’s agenda.

There are practical ways to stay connected with client learning. Regular coaching check-ins can help clients recognise what is emerging, rather than leaving all reflection until the final moments. We discuss how to use these questions in service of the client, alongside noticing our own urge to strive, taking a breath and returning to coaching presence.

Our conversation also considers people pleasing, pride in our work, relationship dynamics and the feelings that can surface when we begin charging for coaching.

We finish with a different question: are we creating the conditions in which something valuable can happen? That shift invites us to trust the coaching process, recognise the client’s contribution and bring our uncertainties into supervision.

Timestamps:

00:00 Welcome and introduction
00:06 Am I adding value as a coach?
00:51 Taking the question into supervision
01:45 Using check-ins to support client learning
03:06 Who decides what counts as value?
04:29 When coaching value is not immediately visible
05:25 Why experienced coaches can question their impact
08:07 Introducing tools for the client’s benefit
09:20 A client story: discovering the impact ten years later
11:42 What would change if you had nothing to prove?
12:32 Exploring approval, pride and people pleasing
15:09 Returning to presence when striving appears
15:48 Exploring relationship and systemic dynamics
16:53 Creating the conditions for value
17:47 How clients contribute to the value of coaching
18:57 Session length, expectations and trusting the time available
20:08 Charging for coaching and feelings of worthiness
21:08 Supervision, coach training and further development

Key Lessons Learned:

Value can emerge after the coaching ends. A client may need time to process an experience before recognising its influence.
A breakthrough is one possible outcome. Thinking space, being heard and exploring uncertainty can also be valuable.
Check-ins should support the client’s learning. Asking what is emerging helps clients recognise their own discoveries.
Experience can bring additional pressure. Recommendations and previous successes can increase our expectations of what each session should achieve.
Our toolkit needs to serve the client’s agenda. Before introducing an activity, we can consider whether the client needs it or whether we are seeking reassurance.
Self-awareness helps us return to presence. Noticing an urge to prove ourselves gives us an opportunity to pause, breathe and reconnect with the client.
Value is co-created. The client’s goals, engagement and willingness to explore shape what becomes possible.
Supervision offers space to examine the question. We can explore how approval, professional pride, money and relationship dynamics influence our practice.

Keywords:

Am I adding value as a coach, coaching supervision, coaching effectiveness, coaching self-doubt, non-directive coaching, client learning, coaching check-ins, coaching presence, client transformations, trust the coaching process, charging for coaching, people pleasing, The Coaching Crowd Podcast,

Links & Resources:

Website: https://igcompany.com/

Take Our Quiz - Which Coaching Course is Right For Me?

Yes take me there!

Join our community of aspiring and practising coaches!

Join us to receive the latest news and updates from Jo and Zoe.

We value your privacy and your information will never be shared.

Am I Adding Value as a Coach?

Take Our Quiz - Which Coaching Course is Right For Me?

Join our community of aspiring and practising coaches!

Join Our Free Trial